Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 17 November 2010

TV review

Britain's trillion pound horror story

EVER SINCE the worldwide economic recession started in 2008, Britain's bankers and big business have been trying to avoid responsibility for the crisis. They prefer to put the blame on what they label a 'bloated' public sector. On 11 November free-marketeer Martin Durkin was allowed 90 minutes of TV airtime by Channel 4 to broadcast a pro-capitalist propaganda film. SEAN FIGG reviews Britain's Trillion Pound Horror Story.

THE FILM argues for low taxes and an end to redistributive policies by abolishing or severely cutting such taxation as inheritance tax and corporation tax. This strategy of minimum government, Durkin claims, will stimulate economic recovery and stop Britain drowning in its £4.8 trillion public debt. In the context of the Con-Dem government's spending cuts this was a thoroughly reactionary broadcast.

Many people are worried about the cuts and would prefer them not to happen, but see no alternative. Durkin provided economic arguments for this 'no alternative' camp which will be used to bamboozle the rest of us. So it's worth replying to some points.

Durkin casts the public sector as a wasteful bureaucracy that does nothing but 'burden' the private - 'productive' - sector of the economy. He says the public sector is paid for by taxing the private sector and that wealth is only created in the private sector. He argues that unless the public sector is scaled back and the private sector expands - as Cameron and Osborne promise us - UK public debt will continue to rise and the country will go bankrupt.

False argument

Firstly, it is false to paint the sources of wealth in such a black and white way. Public sector workers provide services that society generally cannot do without. Also, Durkin presents this 'parasitic' character of the public sector as intrinsic to public ownership. It is not.

This 'division' is a policy choice by pro-big business governments over decades. They chose to allow 'wealth-creating' enterprises to exist almost exclusively in the private sector to the profit of politicians' rich mates. Before the 1980s Thatcher privatisation spree, 'wealth generating' industries such as shipbuilding, steel, coal and telecoms were run in the public sector. This is true today in many countries.

Durkin's argument only holds up if the current division of what is 'public' and what is 'private' in Britain is viewed as fixed forever. Socialists argue for the commanding heights of the economy - the 'wealth-generating' parts - to be taken into public ownership too. Society could then use the wealth created by these enterprises directly rather than just a portion through taxation. Such policy is anathema to Durkin's free-market prejudices.

Durkin blames the huge public debt on politicians who "spent money they didn't have". The film shows that governments borrow money from "financial markets and pension funds" (amongst others) who will whack up the interest on these loans to insure themselves against making a loss if they become less confident about a government's ability to pay them back.

One question is completely ignored: how come these people have all this money to loan in the first place? The capitalist system piles up huge wealth on the plates of a tiny minority. At root this happens because working people are paid less than the value of the wealth they create by working.

Who are the bigger thieves here? For Durkin the super-rich have a sacred right to hold entire countries to ransom and demand spending cuts. But isn't the money loaned to governments ours as well? Durkin just points the finger at one gang of thieves so that another far bigger gang can make a quick getaway.

Durkin's film doesn't deal with the reality of capitalism. His analysis, diagnosis and proposed treatments are mere abstractions plucked straight out of a capitalist economics textbook. For example Durkin tries to prove the efficiency of capitalism over state intervention. He remarks, "inefficient companies go bankrupt" because customers can "take their business elsewhere". But this did not happen to the banks.

Capitalism has moved beyond this textbook myth of equal competition amongst many competing individuals and firms on a level playing field. The reality of 21st century capitalism is monopoly and companies 'too big to fail'. Marxists pointed to this development and its causes - deep in the internal contradictions of capitalism - over a century ago, but Durkin hasn't caught up with us yet.

But if Durkin could enact his low tax, minimal state 'utopia' tomorrow, would any of these reforms have prevented the economic crisis? The answer has to be a resounding no.

Allowing even more of the economy to be driven purely for profit by scaling back the state and letting the wealth gap reach ever more staggering heights through minimal taxation would have blown the same bubbles that led to the world economic crisis.

None of the contradictions of capitalism that make crises inevitable can be 'fixed' by Durkin's proposals. To iron out these contradictions, socialist policies of public ownership of 'wealth-generating' industry and democratic planning would be necessary.

Economic crises never feature in the capitalists' textbooks. They don't understand them because they don't understand how their own system works.

Durkin completely misses the point. He won't end boom and bust by tinkering with tax and it was the bust - the economic crisis and resulting bank bailouts - that massively contributed to the sky-rocketing of the public debt he worries about. More of the same definitely won't help!

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 17 November 2010:

Socialist Party youth and students

Fight for your future!

Massive student demo shows anti-cuts anger

24 November - Strike against fees and cuts

Defend student protesters!

10 November demonstration: Students fighting back

War and occupation

Afghanistan: Withdraw the troops now!

Socialist Party workplace news

Kirklees - fighting £400 million budget cut

Protests and meetings against the cuts

Victory in law centre battle

Jobs threat in Knowsley

Ballot cancelled in BA dispute

National Shop Stewards Network: Anti-cuts conference

Workplace news in brief

Socialist Party news and analysis

Universal Credit - a thinly veiled attack on the sick and unemployed

Coalition turns back the clock on justice

Tories promote fast food nation

Fast news

Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition

The Trade Unionist and Socialist Coalition launches its campaign for the 2011 local elections

International socialist news and analysis

Ireland: 'Not simply a crisis but an absolute disaster'

Ireland: United Left Alliance to challenge at next general election

Support the Laura Ashley strikers

Socialist Party review

Britain's trillion pound horror story


Home   |   The Socialist 17 November 2010   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate  

Related links:


triangleCan you donate to the Socialism 2017 appeal?

triangleObesity epidemic: end food market anarchy

triangleTories torn - bin them now

triangleThe end of the Tories?

triangleNasty party out the Tories


triangleSocialist Students launched in USA

Public sector:

triangleConference on state spies and sabotage: who's watching who?

triangleUnite local government sector plans strike ballot

triangleTories scrap the NHS pay cap: now fight for real-terms pay rises!

Big business:

triangleThe Tories must be driven out

triangleReject Starmer's Single Market u-turn


triangleDefuse the consumer debt time bomb: nationalise the banks!


triangleRussia, October 1917: When workers took power


triangleOctober 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'


triangleYoung people being strangled by debts

Reviews and comments

Reviews and comments


Port Talbot

Powerful picture of the Port Talbot steel workers' struggle


Russian revolution

October 1917 reviews: 'More bright than any heaven'


Theresa May

Theresa May, Frida Kahlo and turning women into wares



Poverty, repression and fightback on the docks


The Socialist

The Socialist Inbox



Shocking insight into Isis



Hugh Hefner's exploitation of women



Women's football - Sampson allegations



The Socialist Inbox



Interview: the "socialist John Le Carré"



Refreshing, anticapitalist - but little pointing a way forward



New documentary asks women how their bodies are sexualised and policed



The Socialist inbox


Che Guevara

Intimate insight into a revolutionary icon



Bosses' pensions robbery

triangleMore Reviews and comments articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle13 Oct The end of the Tories?

triangle11 Oct Nasty party out the Tories

triangle11 Oct CWU fights court attempt to stop national strike

triangle11 Oct The fight against racial discrimination is tied to fighting against...

triangle11 Oct Catalonia: Workers can finish what Puigdemont won't

triangle6 Oct Boeing bust-up threatens thousands of skilled jobs

triangle4 Oct The nasty party turns on itself... but the Tories must be driven out

More ...

triangle18 Oct Warrington & St Helens Socialist Party: 1917-2017; the October Russian Revolution

triangle18 Oct Hackney Socialist Party: 100 years ago - the Bolshevik-led revolution

triangle18 Oct Tower Hamlets Socialist Party: Capitalism in Crisis - is Corbyn the answer?

triangle19 Oct Waltham Forest Young Socialists: Deaths in police custody

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



October 2017

September 2017

August 2017

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017





















Platform setting: = No platform choice