Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/issue/942/25140

From The Socialist newspaper, 29 March 2017

The Socialist's series on the 100th anniversary of the Russian Revolution

April 1917: how the Bolsheviks reorientated

Vladimir Lenin, one of the central leaders of the 1917 Russian revolution, photo German Federal Archive (Creative Commons)

Vladimir Lenin, one of the central leaders of the 1917 Russian revolution, photo German Federal Archive (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

Paula Mitchell, Socialist Party executive committee

On 3 April 1917, Bolshevik leader Vladimir Lenin returned to Russia from exile. Lenin's arrival turned the Bolshevik party upside down and changed the course of history.

Just weeks earlier, demanding an end to the bloody slaughter of World War One, the masses of working class and poor in Russia had risen up in a revolution and driven out the Tsar and government.

But they were not yet conscious of their own power or of what to do. While Bolshevik members were in the workplaces and streets alongside their fellow workers making the revolution, the leaders of the party were still, by necessity, in exile.

Within days of the euphoria of sweeping aside the old regime, instead of the working class and poor taking power themselves, a situation of 'dual power' arose.

Capitalist parties stepped into the vacuum to establish a provisional government - not in order to take the revolution forward in the interests of the majority of the population, but in order to look after their own interests.

Workers' councils - soviets - had arisen in the revolution, and the two main parties that won the leadership were the Mensheviks (the original minority of the workers' movement in Russia) and Social Revolutionaries (a party based on the middle class in the towns and peasants in the countryside).

Even though the Soviets had majority support, the Menshevik and Social Revolutionary soviet leaders voluntarily handed power over to the capitalist provisional government. This included support for the government's continued prosecution of the World War, on the grounds that it was now, they said, a war in defence of the revolution.

Ordinary working class Bolsheviks instinctively knew this was wrong. They thought that the class which had won the victory in February should be the one that took power. But when some of the Bolshevik leaders, including Stalin, returned from exile in March, they took the Bolshevik party sharply to the right and similarly declared support for the provisional government.

Meanwhile, still in exile, desperately seeking ways to return, Lenin was urgently sending telegrams saying what needed to be done: "absolute lack of confidence; no support to the new government".

Lenin calls for socialism

Vladimir Lenin Leon Trotsky Lev Kamenev Russian Revolution Recuerdos de Pandora (Creative Commons), photo Recuerdos de Pandora (Creative Commons)

Vladimir Lenin Leon Trotsky Lev Kamenev Russian Revolution Recuerdos de Pandora (Creative Commons), photo Recuerdos de Pandora (Creative Commons)   (Click to enlarge)

On his arrival in Russia, Lenin was greeted at the train station in Petrograd by dignitaries from the Soviets, expressing the hope that he would join them in their support for the provisional government - one naval officer even suggested he join it.

But Lenin turned away from them. Instead he addressed the thousands of workers, soldiers and sailors who had assembled to greet him. To the horror of the worthies behind him, he declared: "The Russian Revolution achieved by you has opened a new epoch. Long live the world socialist revolution!"

The next day he presented his 'April Theses' to the Bolshevik central committee. This short, terse document, little more than a list of bullet-points, was one of the most important of the revolution.

In it, Lenin argued that the provisional government was a capitalist government and the war was an imperialist war. The working class, leading the peasantry, should take power and begin to carry out a socialist transformation of society.

This threw the Bolshevik party into crisis and at first Lenin was in a minority of one or two.

Up till then, the view of most Marxists, following the model of the capitalist revolutions that had happened in western Europe, was that capitalist democracy needed to be established before socialism. Since there were still substantial feudal elements in Russia, they argued that the revolution had to be a capitalist democratic revolution. To the Mensheviks this meant supporting capitalist parties. Socialism was for the distant future.

After the defeat of the 1905 Russian Revolution, Trotsky had written his theory of 'permanent revolution'. Building on the Marxist understanding of uneven and combined development, he realised that the growth of capitalism and imperialism in the west inevitably impacted on economic and social progress in other parts of the world.

The Russian capitalist class was tiny, frightened by defeat in 1905, and tied to the big landlords and imperialist powers. Most industrial development had actually been driven from the top by the Tsar in order to build up his massive military state power, was reliant on western investment and mostly foreign-owned.

This meant that it would fall to the working class and poor to carry out the tasks that the capitalists had done elsewhere - to distribute land to the peasants, bring about capitalist democracy, and establish a stable nation state.

The Bolshevik party had drawn the same conclusion, and put forward the idea that a government of 'workers and peasants' would be necessary to carry out the capitalist democratic revolution.

But Trotsky drew further conclusions. The peasantry - though the majority in society and the poor sections of it were extremely oppressed - was a disparate, scattered class without a collective outlook.

The working class on the other hand, though numerically smaller, had been thrown together into massive factories and had the ability to organise with a more collective consciousness. It would take a strong lead by the working class to convince the poor peasants that their interests lay with the working class, otherwise they could be pulled behind the ruling class.

Trotsky's permanent revolution theory argued that inevitably the working class wouldn't stop at distributing land to the peasants and democratic measures. In order to satisfy their own interests - a shorter working day, decent wages, etc - the working class would need to press on to socialist tasks, including taking over the factories and the banks. Vitally, the revolution would then have to spread internationally.

Relevant today

Egyptian revolution: Lenin said of revolutions that they demonstrate two things: that the people cannot go on being ruled in the old way. And that the rulers cannot go on ruling in the old way  (Guardian Editorial, 4 February 2011)

Egyptian revolution: Lenin said of revolutions that they demonstrate two things: that the people cannot go on being ruled in the old way. And that the rulers cannot go on ruling in the old way (Guardian Editorial, 4 February 2011)

These ideas are as relevant today as ever. The brutal, exploitative system of capitalism has created a nightmare that destroys the lives of masses of people in Syria, Iraq, Libya - killing hundreds of thousands and displacing millions, who then face an additional horrific ordeal as refugees. Starvation again ravages East Africa.

The capitalist classes in the neocolonial world are as weak and as tied to landlordism and imperialism as ever. Capitalism's inability to improve the lives of the masses is stark.

In April 1917 Lenin came to this same position. He said the old formula of the Bolsheviks was obsolete. He argued it was dangerous to create illusions that the capitalist provisional government would end the war, or meet the demands of the peasants for land or the needs of the workers.

Instead, an independent working class position was essential. It was necessary to wage a struggle to convince the soviets to take power.

By the end of April Lenin had successfully convinced the party. Worker Bolshevik members found Lenin's arguments made sense of their experience of the previous few months and of events as they developed every day. The truth of this was shown in the growth of the party just in those few weeks.

Lenin understood that at that stage the Bolsheviks were in a minority in the working class. They had only 1-2% of support in the soviets in February and about 4% in April.

Just as Socialist Party members do today, although of course in much more heightened circumstances in 1917, the job of the Bolsheviks was to live and fight alongside the best layers of the working class and the masses and "patiently explain".

They developed a programme to appeal to workers, peasants and soldiers with demands and slogans - 'bread, peace and land'.

The masses of working and poor people would learn through experience that the provisional government could give them neither peace nor land.

No dogma, living theory

None of what Lenin and Trotsky were arguing was abstract theory but was a result of real living forces and developments. There was an upsurge of workers and peasants in the next few weeks and months. Workers were struggling on their own demands - to end the war, for shorter working hours, for better pay, for bread.

Under the provisional government, very little was changing. The war continued, workers were still being sent to die. In fact, in April, foreign minister Miliukov ordered an offensive by Russian troops.

Soldiers refused to comply and masses of people demonstrated. The factories remained in the hands of the capitalist bosses, the land remained in the hands of the big landlords. Workers struck, peasants seized the land.

On the demonstrations, workers demanded "Down with Miliukov!" Some also chanted "Down with the provisional government!" While the strongest proponent of the idea that the provisional government needed to be overthrown, Lenin also understood that this was premature.

While sections of the working class were starting to draw this conclusion, the majority still had illusions in the provisional government. It was necessary to still "patiently explain".

This serious approach, in tune with the level of understanding of the masses, working to win people over rather than issuing empty phrases, was a key reason why the Bolshevik party was able to grow, and is an essential lesson for socialists to learn today.

The truth was, as Lenin warned in April, that to attempt to stick to the Menshevik position of support for the provisional government would have meant undermining the working class. In practice it would have led to bloody counter-revolution.

The most important lesson of April 1917 is the role of a revolutionary party and of leadership. The main feature of a revolution is that the masses of the working class move centre stage and make their own history. In 1917 it was the masses that drove events. But it was the leadership of Lenin and Trotsky, and the Bolshevik party, that ensured victory in October. In the course of 1917 the Bolshevik Party became a mass party, the most democratic in history.

A revolutionary party is necessary to organise, generalise, point the way forward, say what needs to be done. The working class is made up of all different kinds of people: different genders, ethnic origins, ages, levels of understanding and experience, etc. The ruling class tries to exploit these divisions - the role of a revolutionary party is to unite workers. And in that party, a leadership with authority, experience and determination is needed.

The next few months saw huge twists and turns. But by the autumn the Bolsheviks had won a majority in soviet after soviet.

The re-arming of the party in April was fundamental to the ability of the working class and poor to take power into their own hands in October 1917, to end Russia's involvement in the murderous world war, and begin to build towards a new, socialist society.

The world today is not the same as 1917. But the gap between rich and poor around the world is greater than ever before. Even in wealthy Europe, Tory austerity, passed on by right-wing Labour councils, kills and inflicts poverty in Britain, while EU-enforced austerity drags Greek people in particular through the dirt.

A rebellion against the establishment, austerity and the rich, has begun - expressed in the Brexit vote, the rejection of the 'lesser evil' Hilary Clinton, the rise of left (and right) populist organisations such as Podemos in Spain, and the support for anti-austerity policies when they were espoused by Jeremy Corbyn's election campaigns.

The lessons of the Russian Revolution are essential today. In Britain we see an attempt by liberal pro-capitalist forces to lead and shape the first shoots of rebellion against austerity by trying to bring people together behind right-wing Labour, Lib Dem and even Tory 'leaders'.

Meanwhile in the Labour Party, instead of making a stand against Blairite pro-capitalist MPs and councillors and putting forward a clear socialist programme, the people around Jeremy Corbyn conciliate in the vain hope of achieving 'unity'.

A clear independent working class position, boldly but "patiently" arguing a socialist alternative, is essential.

The April Theses

by VI Lenin

2.50 including postage - cheques to 'Socialist Books'

For more titles on the Russian Revolution and Marxist classics go to leftbooks.co.uk

bookshop@socialistparty.org.uk

PO Box 24697, London E11 1YD

020 8988 8789

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.


In The Socialist 29 March 2017:


What we think

Unite against terror, racism and war


Socialist Party news and analysis

NHS: protest, strike, occupy to win!

No to racist scapegoating: oppose the far right

Top banks post 67% of profits in tax havens - nationalise the banks!

Prescription and dental charges to rise again - fight for a free NHS!

Homelessness agencies accused of being complicit in coercive deportations

Leeds Labour councillors resign over cuts

Times makes call for Tory entryism

Martin McGuinness: from IRA leader to Stormont minister


Russian revolution 1917-2017

April 1917: how the Bolsheviks reorientated


Workplace news and analysis

Doncaster: snap strike by posties pushes bully bosses back

Over a thousand march with Durham TAs against 23% pay cut

Join the 31 March PCS pay protest

Bridgend Ford overtime stoppage in sourcing dispute

Forest Hill school in Lewisham fights back

Dispute against backdoor privatisation of mental health services

Ballot papers go out in Unite elections

Fujitsu strikes: Manchester and Warrington

Deliveroo victory in Leeds

TUSC backs RMT struggle against Merseyrail


Socialist readers' comments and reviews

Universal Credit is making the housing crisis worse

Save Cardiff's live music venues

Women need secure jobs and equal pay, not patronising 'returnships'

Why I Joined: "I joined Socialist Party to campaign to save the NHS"

The Socialist Inbox


International socialist news and analysis

South Africa: Unity against poverty, crime and xenophobia

Belarus: movement developing against regime


Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Jobstown Not Guilty: defend the right to protest

Angry march against Bradford council-approved incinerator

GMB union should support anti-fracking campaigners in Fylde

"Save our Nurseries", Tower Hamlets campaigners tell the council

South Yorkshire Freedom Riders celebrate three years of fighting

Memorial meeting remembers Bernard Roome

Save Plymouth's libraries!

May Day greetings in the Socialist


 

Home   |   The Socialist 29 March 2017   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook






Related links:

Russian revolution:

triangleBristol South Socialist Party: What does the Russian revolution mean today?

triangleBristol North Socialist Party: History of the Russian Revolution

triangleCardiff Socialist Party: Russian Revolution centenary - the April Theses

triangleWaltham Forest Socialist Party: Was the Russian Revolution a coup?

triangleSalford Socialist Party: Russian Revolution 1917 - the April Theses

Bolsheviks:

triangleWhat went wrong in Russia?

triangleSalford: International Women's Day meeting

triangleInternational Women's Day: taking action against capitalist oppression

triangleLessons of Russia 1917 for women's struggle today

The Socialist:

triangleThe Socialist inbox

triangleHow Blairism sank its claws into the Labour Party

triangleThe Socialist inbox

Socialist:

triangleProtests in solidarity with LGBT+ people facing persecution in Chechnya

triangleBristol Socialist Party: An informal discussion

Russian:

triangleLeeds Socialist Party: Russian Revolution - from February to April 1917

Revolution:

triangleRelaunch of socialistworld.net

Working class:

triangleJobstown trial begins

Government:

triangleTUSC's programme for local jobs and services

Lenin:

triangleReading Socialist Party: The April Theses by Lenin

Trotsky:

triangleLivingstone, Labour and anti-Semitism

Historic events

Historic events

26/4/17

May Day

The real origins of May Day

26/4/17

Labour Party

How Blairism sank its claws into the Labour Party

29/3/17

Russian revolution

April 1917: how the Bolsheviks reorientated

8/3/17

Ferries

1987 Zeebrugge disaster

1/3/17

Russian revolution

Lessons of Russia 1917 for women's struggle today

22/2/17

Russian revolution

February revolution 1917 - what lessons for today?

18/1/17

Revolution

1917revolution.org website to launch

18/1/17

Revolution

Trotsky and February 1917

26/10/16

Jarrow

Jarrow March: an inspiring show of solidarity between workers and youth

19/10/16

Wales

Aberfan: a disaster that should never have happened

19/10/16

Paul Robeson

The radical life of Paul Robeson

19/10/16

Egypt

Suez 1956: the decline of British imperialism and rise of the colonial revolution

28/9/16

Fascism

Cable Street: When workers united and fought the fascist threat at Cable Street

10/8/16

Grunwick

Grunwick strike 40 years on - lessons of an epic battle

27/7/16

Olympics

Barcelona 1936: the people's Olympics

triangleMore Historic events articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle26 Apr Health Campaigns Together meets to chart the way forward

triangle26 Apr TUSC's programme for local jobs and services

triangle26 Apr Jobstown trial begins

triangle26 Apr The real origins of May Day

triangle26 Apr How Blairism sank its claws into the Labour Party

triangle26 Apr BMW strikers determined to win pensions dispute

triangle25 Apr A bold socialist campaign could get rid of the Tories

More ...

triangle2 May Doncaster TUSC election rally: Tories Out, Corbyn4PM, Socialist Steve for mayor

triangle2 May Manchester Socialist Party: Can Corbyn win on socialist policies?

triangle2 May Bristol Socialist Party: Kick he Tories out!

triangle2 May Merseyside TUSC pre-election public meeting

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice