Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page:

From The Socialist newspaper, 2 November 2016

Will workers on company boards make bosses accountable?

Toolworkers mass meeting at British Leyland Longbridge in 1977, photo Dave Evans

Toolworkers mass meeting at British Leyland Longbridge in 1977, photo Dave Evans   (Click to enlarge)

Bill Mullins, Southwark Socialist Party

In her Tory party conference speech on 5 October, Theresa May sought to reposition the 'nasty party' more to the centre and away from the legacy of Thatcher.

Claiming the Tories to be the "party of workers", May said there will be consumers and workers represented on company boards, while employment rights will be protected and enhanced.

Given that the Tories have introduced more anti-trade union laws since they won the 2015 general election these 'promises' look highly unlikely to say the least.

The reference to workers' representatives on company boards also has many dangers.

The bosses have from time to time played with this idea - not to give more say to their workers but to try and ensnare the workforce. The idea is to make workers responsible for the state of the company, without giving them any real say.

The Tories recognise that the growing discontent of the mass of working people with the way the economy is developing - not for them but for the small super-rich minority - is leading to a groundswell of opposition to their rule.

This has manifested itself around the Corbyn movement in the political sphere, but in the future it will begin to also develop in opposition to the bosses in the workplace (see Trade Unions and the Gig Economy, Socialism Today, October 2016).

The idea that workers' representatives on the boards of companies will make any difference is a complete myth. The only real way that workers will have an effective say in what is going on is through strong trade union organisation.

Jeremy Corbyn recognised this in his Labour conference speech: "We will strengthen working people's representation at work and the ability of trade unions to organise so that working people have a real voice at work."

In the 1970s, when trade union membership was twice the size it is now (13 million peak in 1979 compared to today's 6.5 million), the capitalist class was desperate to curtail the strength of the unions at work. One idea they came up with was also having workers' representatives on the management boards of the big companies.

The 1977 Bullock report (named after Lord Bullock, the chairman of the committee charged by the Labour government to introduce so-called 'workers' democracy') proposed a system of a single tier company board made up of shareholders and union members with equal representation and another third chosen by the first two parts (the so called 2 X+Y group).

Militant, forerunner of the Socialist, explained that this was an attempt to "marry the irreconcilable interests of the capitalist class and the working class".

As long as the economy is in private ownership and subject to the periodic crises of capitalism, then the system proposed by Bullock (backed up by the trade union leaders on the committee) would mean the workers and their trade unions taking responsibility for carrying through mass sackings and plant closures to make the companies profitable against their competitors!

This was the system developed in Germany in the post-war period known as 'co-determination' - with workers on supervisory boards but with no right to strike, rubber stamping the business decisions of the directors.

One worker representative after experiencing this process said what they wanted instead was "a shop stewards system similar to the one in Britain".

In the 1970s at British Leyland (the former UK car manufacturer) the commercial crisis in the company led to the independence of the shop stewards committees being undermined by what was called a "participation committees system" (read more in Bill's book 'On The Track').

Only strong trade union organisation in the workplace, not the myth of workers on the boards of big companies, is effective in improving workers' pay and conditions. Real workers' management can only be achieved by implementing socialist policies - nationalising major industry under democratic workers' control and management.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.

In The Socialist 2 November 2016:

What we think

Corbyn movement must seize initiative - or face defeat

Socialist Party news and analysis

Fight for decent jobs for all

Fight the 'burning' of our museums and libraries!

Battle of Orgreave: Establishment cover up continues

One third of 2010's new teachers have already quit

We are all Daniel Blake: no more deaths from benefit cuts

LGBT people need militancy, not false 'allies' like David Cameron

What we saw

Refugee solidarity

Solidarity with refugees

Demolition of Calais 'Jungle' camp - eyewitness report

My time in a detention centre

Socialist Party youth and students

Mass student strike rocks Spanish state

Glasgow School of Arts students "let us learn" revolt

International socialist news and analysis

EU-Canada trade deal battle points to Corbyn's Brexit opportunity

Environment and socialism

Heathrow expansion exposes Tory divisions

Socialist Party feature

Will workers on company boards make bosses accountable?

Workplace news and analysis

Sheffield bin workers' action strengthens in numbers and mood

Solid Southern strike continues against Britain's 'worst' train company

Newsquest strike: "It's impossible to do our jobs"

Outsourced ambulance workers strike in Tooting

Socialist Party reports and campaigns

Glenfield heart unit closure: Over 1,000 march

Massive demo against A&E closure

Campaigners call on Greenwich council to oppose the Housing Act

Haringey care services face ruthless cuts and privatisation

Teaching assistants stage vigil and rally

"Our problems cannot be solved by capitalist politics"


Home   |   The Socialist 2 November 2016   |   Join the Socialist Party

Subscribe   |   Donate   |   Audio  |   PDF  |   ebook

Related links:

Shop Stewards:

triangleUnite day of action against blacklisting

triangleObituary: Derek Robinson, car workers' leader, 1927-2017

triangleNSSN meeting brings together workers in struggle

triangleStrike together for better pay

triangleTories weak: time for the TUC to act


triangle15 years since the invasion of Iraq: what we said

triangleSocialist Party congress 2018

triangleSainsbury's raise really a cut: fight for 10 with no strings!

triangleWorkplace news in brief


triangleCampaigners continue to demand Chorley A&E is fully reopened

triangleStrike continues: set dates for next national action

triangleDetermined UCU strikers: We're out to win!

Trade union:

triangleWoolwich ferry workers win automation campaign

triangleFor workplace trade union organisation against sexual harassment


triangleLeaked pay deal: fight for a genuine pay rise


triangleYork Socialist Party: Building and financing a revolutionary party


triangleSpring Statement 2018: Tory austerity staggers on despite economic and political weakness

Working class:

triangleContinuing the fighting tradition of working class women


triangleSpain: millions on streets against sexism and capitalist oppression

Reports and campaigns

Reports and campaigns


Socialist Party

Socialist Party congress 2018



Strike continues: set dates for next national action


Socialist Party

Members dig deep into their pockets to support the party


North West

Campaigners continue to demand Chorley A&E is fully reopened



Swansea Labour council votes for cuts



Derby public meeting: Women's Lives Matter



Seeing-off the bigoted, billionaire toff!



Continuing the fighting tradition of working class women



Workplace news in brief



Leicester: Blairites block Labour Party democracy



Leaked pay deal: fight for a genuine pay rise



We feel that we will win - a striker speaks



Woolwich ferry workers win automation campaign



UCU strike: bosses on the run



Salford nurseries consultation delayed

triangleMore Reports and campaigns articles...

Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party
Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube



Phone our national office on 020 8988 8777


Locate your nearest Socialist Party branch Text your name and postcode to 07761 818 206

Regional Socialist Party organisers:

Eastern: 0798 202 1969

East Mids: 0773 797 8057

London: 020 8988 8786

North East: 0191 421 6230

North West 07769 611 320

South East: 020 8988 8777

South West: 07759 796 478

Southern: 07833 681910

Wales: 07935 391 947

West Mids: 02476 555 620

Yorkshire: 0114 264 6551



Alphabetical listing

March 2018

February 2018

January 2018