Join the Socialist Party Join us today!

Printable version Printable version

Facebook   Twitter

Link to this page: http://www.socialistparty.org.uk/articles/25650

Posted on 14 June 2017 at 17:13 GMT

Massive failings led to Grenfell Tower fire - Rapid, fully funded action now

Paul Kershaw, London Socialist Party

The fire at Grenfell Tower in west London spread with horrific speed and witnesses have described heart-rending scenes as residents attempted to escape. This is a terrible tragedy and there has naturally been an outpouring of sympathy and human solidarity with the residents and families affected.

There have been many fatalities and 74 people were taken to hospital; more than 20 ambulance crews attended. Details will come in over time but the courage of firefighters and local residents is immediately clear. We salute the courage of the firefighters, local residents and ambulance crews who responded with self-sacrificing speed.

But as well as huge sympathy and sorrow, there has been a big expression of anger from local people.

Members of the Unite housing workers' branch report that, all over London, residents were approaching housing workers with their fears about the implications. There is real anger that residents' concerns have not been listened to and that the terrible events may have been avoidable.

There has been a history of problems with maintenance of the block and residents have expressed concern at fire safety. Residents' organisation Grenfell Action Group said they had repeatedly warned the owners of the block, Kensington and Chelsea Tory council, and Kensington and Chelsea Tenant Management Organisation, which manages the block, about "very poor fire safety standards" in the tower. They claimed their warnings "fell on deaf ears".

Although Kensington and Chelsea is the richest part of the UK, it includes many working class residents. In fact, anger at the housing situation in the borough is one of the factors behind the surprise victory for the Labour candidate, who had campaigned on housing, in last week's general election.

As well as the imperative need to rehouse the survivors, there is the issue of residents in surrounding blocks. They were evacuated because of the fire, but have now been moved back in - although the nearest tube stations are shut due to fears of debris falling on the line.

Many residents are worried that their homes are unsafe. This needs answers. If not safe, these other residents must be immediately accommodated elsewhere. If it is safe, issues such as the lack of hot water - the boiler for some surrounding blocks was in Grenfell Tower - must urgently be addressed.

The borough has 1,399 empty properties, mostly owned by the rich.

Advice to residents in Grenfell Tower was to stay in their flats in the event of fire because fire insulation would give time for emergency services to reach them. Survivors say how glad they are that they ignored this advice given the speed of spread.

Questions on refurbishment

Witnesses speak of the recently fitted outer cladding on the tower catching fire, raising questions about the fire-resistance of the materials - such questions are not new in housing. Notably, the Guardian's Dawn Foster reports that Rydon, the company responsible for the cladding and retrofitting refurbishments at Grenfell Tower, has scrapped all references to the refurbishment from its website.

Outrageously, according to an article on the Independent's website: "that cladding - a cheap way of improving the front of the building - was added in part so that the tower would look better when seen from the conservation areas and luxury flats that surround north Kensington, according to planning documents".

Grenfell demonstrator, 17.6.17  , photo Mary Finch

Grenfell demonstrator, 17.6.17 , photo Mary Finch   (Click to enlarge)

Research by the Times newspaper has found that a version of the cladding with a "non-combustible" core would have cost a mere 5,000 more. That would have added 0.0006% to the reported 8.6 million refurbishment cost.

And Kensington and Chelsea Tenant Management Organisation papers show they hired a fire risk consultant who "was willing to challenge the fire brigade on our behalf if he considered their requirements to be excessive." Their other consideration seems to be that he offered the "most competitive price."

It was described as an "unprecedented situation" by the London Fire Brigade. Matt Wrack of the firefighters' union the FBU, on Sky, said it shouldn't be possible for fire to develop in this way and the union is calling for a major investigation to be made into the building. A call echoed by the Unite housing workers' branch.

As with the recent terrorist attacks, this horrendous event also brings into sharp focus the fact that the number of firefighters has been cut in London by 550, with ten stations closed and others with appliances reduced. The number of fire deaths has risen over the last year and figures for waiting times in accident and emergency departments and ambulance response times have failed to meet targets. NHS services are at breaking point and facing further cuts.

National implications

The causes of this fire are not yet confirmed but there must be concern that the issues raised point to unacceptable risk around the country.

The All-Party Parliamentary Fire Safety and Rescue Group of MPs has been calling for a review of building regulations for years. Failings were uncovered following a devastating tower block fire at Lakanal House in Southwark in 2009, which killed six people. The failings then included a lack of fire risk assessments, and panels on the outside walls not providing the necessary fire resistance.

Then-housing minister Gavin Barwell said in the Commons last October that the government will review Part B of Building Regulations 2010, which relate to fire safety, "following the Lakanal House fire". Ronnie King, a former chief fire officer and secretary to the parliamentary committee said the building regulations "haven't taken account of the Lakanal House fire inquest, or updated recent accredited research" (Inside Housing, 7 March 2017).

In fact, research by Inside Housing, an industry magazine, found in 2015 that just 1% of tower blocks have sprinklers fitted, in spite of the Lakanal findings.

The issue was that cladding to improve heat insulation undermined fire safety. Inside Housing magazine was unable to get a date for the review from the government at that time. Gavin Barwell, the housing minister responsible at the time the building regulations review was delayed, lost his seat in last week's election and has now been parachuted in as Theresa May's chief of staff.

A survey by the Department for Communities and Local Government in February found that regulations are "far too complex" to guarantee high-quality buildings. The judge in the Lakanal inquest called them "incomprehensible." But when Barwell was pressed on the matter in March, he was still stonewalling about a review of the regulations.

Chancellor Philip Hammond has said the cladding is banned in the UK - but the above evidence suggests it could be difficult to tell if this is the case. The manufacturer disputes it, of course.

Either way, members of West London Socialist Party spoke to another Socialist Party member who is a construction engineer. The engineer believes bad practice is very prevalent, particularly among small contractors such as used here - and says that councils' cutbacks mean effective enforcement of regulations is almost non-existent.

Simply changing the building regulations would not be an adequate response as existing buildings would need to be reviewed. The cost implications could be significant but austerity cannot be allowed to delay a response.


The above article was expanded and updated on 19.6.17.


West London Socialist Party member Bob Sulatycki commented:

"It's already quite clear that this isn't a tragic accident but the predicted and criminal result of the policies of cuts, privatisation, lack of democratic accountability and wilful neglect carried out locally and nationally.
All tenants in social housing in the area and beyond will be thinking about the importance of what's happened.
There are ongoing cuts to NHS provision in the area, including to the A&Es at Charing Cross and other local hospitals that are currently taking casualties but are faced with cuts and closures."


Read more - urgent action needed

Latest on Grenfell


This version of this article was first posted on the Socialist Party website on 14 June 2017 and may vary slightly from the version subsequently printed in The Socialist.

Why not click here to join the Socialist Party, or click here to donate to the Socialist Party.






Related links:

London:

triangleEast London Socialist Party: Workers' struggles across Europe

triangleWaltham Forest Socialist Party: Report from the CWI summer school

triangleBarts health strike: Low pay, no way!

triangleLambeth Socialist Party: What is Socialism?

triangleGrenfell survivors tell Tories: "Step down and resign"

Fire:

triangleYoung Socialists off to a flying start in Cardiff

triangleTenants' meeting reveals huge anger

triangleVigil for Grenfell

triangleGrenfell stitch-up: unions should call independent inquiry

Housing:

triangleHomelessness and evictions soar under the Tories

triangleBron Afon workers strike against 3,000 pay cut

triangleBron Afon workers fight 3,000 pay cut

Cuts:

triangleSouthampton councillors faced with angry anti-cuts campaigners

triangleEducation cuts forced back

Firefighters:

triangleSurrey FBU pass no confidence motion

Ambulance:

triangleThe Socialist inbox

Austerity:

triangleManchester: national Tories Out demo

Fire service:

triangleWhole establishment exposed for role in Grenfell fire

News and socialist analysis

News and socialist analysis

26/7/17

Debt

Abolish tuition fees and student debt!

26/7/17

Them & Us

Them & Us

26/7/17

Homelessness

Homelessness and evictions soar under the Tories

26/7/17

BBC

BBC yawning pay gaps revealed

26/7/17

Brexit

Right wing attempts to use single market against Corbyn

25/7/17

PCS

Court victory for PCS and all trade unions

19/7/17

Education

Education cuts: Tories buckling under public pressure

12/7/17

Refugees

G20 betrays refugees created by its own policies

12/7/17

Anti-austerity

This bosses' government must go

12/7/17

Trade unions

The left unions and the Labour Party affiliation debate

5/7/17

Abortion

Weakened Tories forced into Northern Ireland abortion u-turn

5/7/17

LGBT

Pride 2017: we need a fighting, socialist movement for LGBT+ rights

5/7/17

Pay

Public sector wages - Pay up!

5/7/17

Grenfell Tower

Fight establishment's Grenfell insults: no to cover-up, safety for all!

5/7/17

Tuition Fees

Tories' tuition fees wobble: fight for free education!

triangleMore News and socialist analysis articles...


Join the Socialist Party
Subscribe to Socialist Party publications
Donate to the Socialist Party

triangle27 Jul 'Scrap the Cap on pay', demand nurses

triangle26 Jul Barts health strike: Low pay, no way!

triangle26 Jul Bin workers stand firm

triangle26 Jul Education cuts forced back

triangle26 Jul Abolish tuition fees and student debt!

triangle26 Jul Building workers' struggle and the forces of international socialism

triangle26 Jul Right wing attempts to use single market against Corbyn

More ...

triangle27 Jul Swansea Socialist Party: Building a Marxist International

triangle27 Jul Cardiff East Socialist Party: Socialist Question Time

triangle27 Jul Lambeth Socialist Party: What is Socialism?

triangle1 Aug Derby Socialist Party: Domestic violence - What are the causes?

More ...

Socialist Party Facebook page
Socialist Party on Twitter
Visit us on Youtube

Archive

Archives:

July 2017

June 2017

May 2017

April 2017

March 2017

February 2017

January 2017

2016

2015

2014

2013

2012

2011

2010

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

Legal

SP RSS feed RSS

Platform setting: = No platform choice

V2